MILITARY
OCCUPATION FORCES
Korea Under the American Military Government, 1945-1948
by Bonnie B. C. Oh (Editor)
Hardcover: 232 pages Publisher: Praeger Pub Text; ISBN: 0275974561; (May 30,
2002)
Price: $64.95
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
This collection, edited by Distinguished Professor of Korean Studies Bonnie
B.C. Oh, helps to fill a considerable gap in the English-language literature on
Korea and the United States. Although much has been written about Korea in the
Japanese colonial and World War II period and, of course, even more has been
made available on the Korean War years, little has been written on the interim
period when the United States attempted to rule Korea through a trusteeship.
About the Author
BONNIE B. C. OH is Distinguished Professor of Korean Studies at the Edmund A.
Walsh School of Foreign Studies at Georgetown University. She has edited and
co-edited a number of books and published numerous artices. Her most recent
authored and co-edited publication is Comfort Women of World War II.
Kalani O'Sullivan Note: There is a 1950s publication with a similar title that
covers the Chollanam-do area and the Military Government performance. The
judgement was that the Military Government was ineffective at best. The
organization of the Military Government was such that though there were "free
elections," but the elected officials reported to the Military Government...not
the people.
Korea Between The Wars
A Soldier's Story
by Fred Ottoboni
ISBN 915241-02-1, paperback, 332 pages including 12 pages of photos.
Price: $19.95
Published by Vincente Books, Inc., PO Box 50704, Sparks, NV 89435. Also
available direct from the publisher, postpaid, $19.95.
Amazon.com readers rate this book as a 4 1/2 star offering. It contains a
wealth of information not only of the conditions during this period, but also
information on Kunsan City of today.
History books are silent on the experiences of United States Army ground troops
that occupied South Korea during the period between the end of World War Two
(1945) and the beginning of the Korean War (1950).
Ample material can be found describing the political events and the military
strategies of the time, but the realities of life during the occupation, as
seen by the soldiers on the ground in Korea, are locked in the memories of the
men still living who served there -- men now approaching the ends of their
lives.
Korea Between The Wars
was written by a soldier who served in the 63rd Infantry Regiment of the 6th
Infantry Division during the American occupation of South Korea. The book
includes photographs and many excerpts from almost 200 letters written to his
family between 1946 and 1948.
Korea Between The Wars
is personal memoir and a history of that time and place. The author, stationed
at Camp Hillenmeyer, on the shore of the Yellow Sea near Kunsan, Korea, tells
of bone-chilling cold, shortages of fuel, few weapons, dirty bodies, grimy
clothes, and hunger to the point of starvation.
The book includes much more than army life. Based on his many letters to his
family, the author describes Korean towns and countryside, the people, their
homes, their ways of life and work. It recounts the food shortages, the
political turmoil, the difficult relations between the Korean people and the
American soldiers, and the numerous signs of the war that was soon to come
between North and South Korea.
The final chapter of the book looks back, with the benefit of time and study,
in an attempt to understand how the military situation in South Korea and
American foreign policy might have invited the Korean War.
Appendices include a brief history of the 6th Division and the 63rd Infantry
Regiment, a list of references, and recommended reading. The book also includes
12 glossy pages of photos taken by the author in Korea.
The author was born in California in 1927, and grew up during the great
depression of the 1930's. His ambition was to be an engineer. While waiting a
military draft call and contemplating his inability to pay for a college
education, he enlisted in the army to both fulfill his military obligation and
to earn the college tuition benefits of the GI Bill.
He served in the army from late 1946 into 1948. He obtained a chemical
engineering degree from Stanford University and later earned a Ph.D. in
industrial hygiene from the University of California. His great interest in
life was the prevention of diseases of occupations and worked at that
profession until retirement in 1995.
The author may be contacted via his email address:
ottoboni@reno.quik.com
Boy Soldier: Coming of Age during World War II
Russell E. McLogan
Hardcover - 432 pages (December 7, 1998)
Price: $29.95
Reviews
Publisher Comments
...a fascinating account of an 18-year-old rifleman who joined K Company, 63rd
Infantry Regiment during some of the 6th Infantry Division's bitterest
fighting...Read this story by putting yourself in the place of this patriotic,
dedicated youth who was motivated to perform his duty in this battle hardened
rifle company...Russ McLogan was a member of the few among millions of
soldiers--the combat infantrymen who spearheaded the war--dragging along behind
them the huge, often cumbersome superstructure of the reat of the Army. [This]
is the story of the elite, the combat infantry, and he was one of those who
survived to tell us about it. Colonel Arndt L. Mueller, USA (RETD) 3rd
Battalion Commander during World War II
On April 14, 1945, Russell E. McLogan joined Company K of the 63rd
Infantry...one of the many youngsters coming into the company...to fill the
void left by casualties. Many of these boys, hardly out of high school, were
soon shot. McLogan himslf got it on June 21, but fortunately survived to return
home, have a family and in retirement write a history of his war
experiences....He is a born researcher, a peruser of archives, an historian.
John L. Munschaer, K Company Platoon Leader and Author in World War II
Cavalcade: An Offer I Couldn't Refuse, Sunflower University Press, 1996
Many people have been aspiring writers, but few have become real writers.
Russell McLogan is a real writer. John Klein, Publisher, Community Plus+
Magazine upon awarding him first prize for the best short story in the 1996
fiction contest.
Book Description
It is said that in order to completely understand a man you should probe the
world as it existed when he was 19 or 20 years old--at the moment he became
mature and autonomous as a man. Russell McLogan has done just that in this
well-written autobiography. Drafted out of college at age 18 in 1944, he was
trained as a rifleman and then sent to the Philippines as an infantry
replacement. There he joined the battle hardened 6th Infantry Division on the
Shimbu Line near Manila. Wounded in combat in northern Luzon, he spent 89 days
in Army hospitals on Luzon and Leyte. When the atomic bomb abruptly ended the
war, he was returned to duty just in time to sail off to Korea where he served
in the Army of Occupation. Boy Soldier is about a young man's coming of age
during this period of tremendous historical change. It includes much
well-researched history of the Army's replacement training system, the
Liberation of the Philippines, the dropping of the atomic bombs, the
American-Russian occupation of Korea, and the Army's post-war
demobilization--the people, places, and events that shaped a young life.
Although written in a scholarly mode with endnotes, bibliography and index, it
is very readable with the humor, violence, sexual situations and sometimes raw
language as it actually happpened. Text is supplemented with 72 illustrations
and 15 maps.
About the Author
Russell E. McLogan, P.E., was born in Detroit, Michigan May 10, 1926. After
graduating from the Henry Ford Trade School and finishing his first semester at
the University of Detroit, he was drafted Sept 15, 1944 and received his
infantry training at Camp Hood, Texas and Fort Ord, California. Russ joined the
6th Infantry Division on the Shimbu Line near Manila where he served in Company
K, 63rd Infantry Regiment. Wounded in combat in Northern Luzon, he spent 89
days in hospitals on Luzon and Leyte. Returned to duty after the war ended, he
served in the Army of Occupation in Korea and was discharged Nov. 2, 1946.
Graduated from the University of Detroit,B.B.A., cum laude, 1953 and a
Registered Mechanical Engineer in Michigan, he held engineering and management
positions with major auto and aerospace companies for over 40 years and retired
in 1989 to pursue a writing career. He has been published in the Emerald Coast
Review, Catholic Digest, Purple Heart Magazine, Community Plus+ Magazine, and
the Hillsdale Daily News. Russ married Terri (Lilly) McLogan in 1950. They have
six children and ten grandchildren. Home has been Hillsdale, Michigan since
1964 with winters spent in Fort Walton Beach, Florida.
Review by Kalani O'Sullivan:
Only one or two chapters at the end deal with Kunsan AB. The 6th Infantry Division was sent up from the Philippines via LST to handle the surrender of Korea. Shipped directly from the warm tropics to frozen Korea, the troops had to use discarded Japanese uniforms to stay warm. The book was well-received. Margaret Everett from Destin, FL , March 11, 1999 wrote, "Boy Soldier is well written and realistic. Boy Soldier vividly gives the reader insight into the thoughts and emotions of an eighteen year old boy thrust into the infantry in World War II. The author is remarkable in his ability to recall the feelings of the "Boy Soldier." Each chapter flowed into the next chapter connecting the events of this great war in the Pacific and capturing the interest of the reader."
The chapters dealing with Korea provide some insights into the conditions in Korea at the time by a young 18-year old soldier. Starting his journey in Inchon (Jinsen) where they off-loaded from the LST he proceeded to Kunsan. The 63rd Regiment of the 6th Infantry Division were to take over the provinces in the southwest. On pg 300, he states, "It took all day to make the trip from Seoul to Kunsan, some 130 miles. It was dark when we arrived at the Japanese Air Base near Kunsan where the third battalion was billeted in wooden barracks." He described the barracks as "very long and constructed of wood. The interior walls were made of paper-tin plywood. A long, narrow, central hallway ran the length of the barracks some 250 or 300 feet. There were small rooms on both sides of the hallway housing offices and sleeping quarters of the men, six or eight to a room. They were unheated and veritable fire traps." He went on, "Apparently the Japanese military were hardy souls who could live in that climate without heating the barracks. We Americans, who had just arrived from a tropical island, were always cold. We had available for our use small portable kerosene stoves. They were about six inches in diameter and eighteen inches high, about the size of a kerosene lantern, with a single burner on top. We used these little stoves mostly to keep warm, but also to make tea or coffee or to boil fresh eggs which we obtained from the local Koreans. Later one of these stoves was accidentally tipped over and the whole barracks was destroyed. (SEE Japanese Aviation Training Base (1938-1945) which is what he saw when he arrived; Occupation Forces: 6th Infantry Division, 63d Infantry Regiment, 3d Battalion; A Soldier's Story (1945-1947) for the miserable conditions after he left; Occupation Forces: 63d Service Company, Kunsan Harbor (1945-1947) for the some photos of Kunsan and Iri; and Occupation Forces: Officer's Tour (1946-1947) for life within Camp Hillenmeyer (renamed for the Capt that he describes) by officer families.)
Later he wrote, "I was back into the routine of an infantry rifle company: close order drill, long marches, calisthenics, training and guard duty. ... It was rice harvesting time in that part of Korea. I spent many cold nights pulling guard duty in the fields. We would be trucked out to the rice paddies for four-hour stints of standing or sitting by piles of harvested grain. I was apppalled when I saw soldiers burning the rice to keep themselves warm."
He added, "When we were not occupied with military duties, we spent time looking around the place. There were hangers and Japanese airplanes to look at. Also a complete machine shop and maintenance stores." This statement is interesting as by 1946, there was only ONE aircraft that was methodically stripped by the Koreans.
He went on, "One building, which must have been officers' quarters, had a mini-swimming pool in it which turned out to be a communal bath tub. ... The Yellow Sea was within walking distance and we often walked down to the shore. The tides in this part of the world are enormous, sometimes running as high as 30 heet. When it was at low tide we could stand on the beach and look out over miles and miles of mud flats with the ocean barely discernible on the horizon. ... We could also catch a ride to town, which was a congested, smelly place of mud houses with thatched roofs. The shops were full of junk that we weren't interested in buying. Hair pomades, for instance. There seemed to be hundreds of jars of the stuff in every other shop. They were also overstocked with incense and equipment to burn it. Some soldiers bought some but got a lot of complaints when they tried burning it in the barracks. ... We were forbidden to eat or drink any of the native foods because they didn't have much and needed what little they did have to keep from starving, and their standards of public health were much lower and the prevalence of communicable intestinal diseases, principally typhoid fever and cholera, was very high. This was because they used human excrement as fertilizer on their farms."
One humorous statement was the combination of human excrement and KIMCHI was the reason for the rank smell of Kunsan. He went on, "Actually, Kunsan was a fairly large city of some 40,000 people at that time. It was Korea's sixth largest port and could accommodate ships of 4000 tons. However, a ship drawing more than eight feet of water could reach the harbor only at high tide. Kunsan was being used to ship out the Japanese and bring in the repatriated Koreans. I heard some mdics talking once about how they had to meet the incoming ships, mostly LCIs and LSTs, and spray delousing powder on the Koreans before they were allowed to board trains for their home towns."
He went on to describe the explosion in the Japanese ammo dump on the South side of the base on Nov 30, 1945. (NOTE: This site remained the ammo storage area for Kunsan AB (K-8) during the Korean War and is the current location of the 8th FW munitions storage area.) Col. Arndt Mueller wrote that Capt. (Henry R.) Hillenmeyer, the S3 Operations Staff Officer along with another officer was killed in this explosion. Col Mueller stated, "There were numerious Korean casualties. Some were the brave firemen...the rest were in the neighboring village. Most of the houses were flattened. A fierce fire broke out. The figure of 300 Korean caualties is not out of line and may even be a low figure. ... This was a tragedy waiting to happen. Every time I went into that dump, my skin would crawl ... Ammo, black powder, picric acid explosives, fuses and blasting caps were all mixed up. Black powder had been spilled on the ground. The Japs did not obeserve the strict ammo storage procedures that we did..." He stated that "Division sent us an explosives expert who was to supervise the job of reducing the dump ... An engineer Lt. in charge of repair of a nearby bridge said that the last he saw of the expert, (just before the explosion), he was standing on top of a pile of explosives directing the Korean firemen in their attempt to put out a fire in the rice stubble inside the dump."
McLogan described how they disposed of the Japanese munitions by dumping them into the sea from flat-bottomed barges. Requests to use the Japanese regiment to do this labor was denied because of the fear that Japanese treachery would create a disaster. After the explosion, Col. Mueller stated, "Division said it was OK to use the Japs to dispose the ammo at sea. They did it without incident ... gave me no trouble -- followed all the rules I laid down to the letter. I even took my guards off their compound."
Later the 3d Battalion's camp would be unofficially be renamed, Camp Hillenmeyer, though the records indicate that it was officially called first Camp Iri and then Camp Kunsan. McLogan wrote, "The Regimental Headquarters had moved from Kunsan to Chonju on November 24. With the regiment spread out over Cholla Pukto province, it affforded a more central location. Chonju, population 47,230, was the provincial capital and like Kunsan was a crowded mass of houses and unpaved roads. The only significant industrieds were a hemp textile mill and a large tobacco factry and warehouse." He was reassigned as a clerk and later switchboard operator in Iri.
He wrote, "It was at ime of transition for the Regiment. Confusion abounded because the regiment had suffered a massive decrease of 715 men in Novemenber (70 officers and 645 enlisted men). Apparently a fourth of the regiment had arrived in Korea, served a few weeks andthen gone home on points. They were the oldest and most experienced soldiers left after had gone in September. Everyone was new on the job and I don't remember getting much direction." He goes on to relate various incidents of the NCO leadership being completely lacking.
An interesting note about the 63rd's history is on pg. 313. "The Unit History also says that by December 31, 1945, the 63rd Infantry had accomplished the following (abridged) missions in Korea:"
- a. Completed the occupation of Cholla-Pukto Province.
- b. Completed the disarmament and evacuation of 3,751 Japanese Army troops to Japan.
- c. Military Government in Cholla-Pukto Provice down to all 14 Guns (Counties) totaling 1,700,000 in population.
- d. Completed the evacuation of 22,095 Jap civilains to Japan.
- e. Established a processing station at the port of Kunsan. At total of 33,845 Koreans from Japan were unloaded and dispatched by rail to relocations centers in Korea. A total of 251 Chinese were dispatched by LST to China.
- f. Approximately 600 tons of Japanese ammunition and explosives were destroyed.
The book is well-written with many vignettes of life in Korea at the time though information dealing specifically with Kunsan -- which is the focus of our website -- is very sparce. However, as there is very little first-hand eye witness accounts of Kunsan, this book becomes a significant piece of historical literature.
The publisher, Russell E. McLogan (terruspress@dmci.net) , April 24, 1999
Comments received from readers have been very favorable.
I would like to share the following with Amazon.com's audience: From Tom
Brokaw, NBC NEWS, Author of "The Greatest Generation," New York: Random House,
1998. "I look forward to reading "Boy Soldier." Thank you for writing and
sharing your own perspective on that era." From Paul Fussell, Author of many
books including "Thank God for the Atom Bomb and other Essays," New York:
Ballantine Books, 1981. : (Russ McLogan). . .shows an admirable talent at
relating historical events to his own actions and feelings. Depite its
unpretentiousness, it is an extraordinary book." From a review in "The
Trailblazer" a publication of the 70th Infantry Division, Spring 1999 by Ed
Lane, editor. "Russ McLogan was an ordinary GI who realized he had lived
through extraordinary times and decided to remember every moment. "Boy Soldier"
is his personal memoir. In the sweep of his story, he weaves it into the
broader historical perspective of the greatest war ever fought...He tells the
story as he lived it; in simple terms, in simple words; conveying the irony,
humor and stark terror that are the make up of war to an infantryman. . .it
details that life in remarkable clarity: in simple language. It will be
interesting to 70th Division men in that it details the jungle war against the
Japanese and not the winter war against the Germans... Highly Recommended.
Margaret Everett from Destin, FL , March 11, 1999
Boy Soldier is well written and realistic.
Boy Soldier vividly gives the reader insight into the thoughts and emotions of
an eighteen year old boy thrust into the infantry in World War II. The author
is remarkable in his ability to recall the feelings of the "Boy Soldier." Each
chapter flowed into the next chapter connecting the events of this great war in
the Pacific and capturing the interest of the reader.
KOREAN WAR
Grim Reapers : History of the Third Bomb Group, 1918-1965
by L. Cortese
All Used from $75.00
Hardcover Historical Aviation Album; ASIN: 0911852948; (December 1985)
Reviews
Kalani O'Sullivan:
This book comes highly recommended by those of the 8th Bomb Group. Many of the
8th's veteran organizations reference this book on their sites. It was out of
print, but I see it has been reissued in time for the Korean War anniversary.
One of the oldest flying units of America, its history dates to WWI and then to
Mexican border duty. One of the first units to enter WWII, it distinguished
itself in the Pacific. After being assigned to Itazuke, Japan, it was one of
the first to launch strikes in the Korean War -- and performed the last combat
mission of that "Forgotten War." In the book, the following statistics are
cited for the 3rd Bombardment Group in Korea: 5,000 vehicles destroyed, 60,000
enemy soldiers killed, 700 surface ships destroyed and 3,000 planes destroyed
on the ground and in the air. And this doesn't count the locomotives... The
unit was inactivated after the Korea War. The 3rd was reactivated as the 3rd
Tactical Fighter Wing reassigned to Kunsan in the early 70s and then made a
move (in name only) to Clark AB, Phillipines. It inherited the name "Grim
Reapers" from the 13th Bomb Squadron (LNI) -- the last to bear the title of
"The Devil's Own Grim Reapers." The 3rd Wing is now in Alaska. Its original
component units went on to become the 90th Fighter Squadron in Alaska and the
8th "Black Birds" of Hurlburt Field, Florida (with the 13th still pending
reactivation).
Involuntary
by Andrew G. Anderson, Chester L. Blunk
Paperback: 156 pages ; Publisher: Xlibris Corporation; ISBN: 0738828939; 1
edition (December 1, 2000)
Price: $20.99
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
On a sunny summer day in June 1950, America was jolted with the news of the
North Korean invasion of South Korea. There was a group of men this news was to
influence greatly. Within 16 days we were back on active duty, training to take
our place in the Korean War.
Not only were we training in an airplane most of us had hardly gotten used to.
To compound that we found we were to be the first Light-Night Attack squadron
in Air Force history. In addition to being in the first Reserve Wing to ever be
recalled intact, this dubious distinction only added to our apprehension.
From the moment of recall on August 10th, 1950 to the end of July, 1951, this
group of Reservists was to write a thrilling saga of what can be accomplished
by men who have the innate sense of patriotism to get the job done.
Flying alone at night, at minimum altitudes over enemy territory is not
conducive to longevity, but this group of air crewmen accomplished much more
than could be expected in the light of circumstances.
Sit back, fasten your seat belt and live the saga of the 731st Bomb Squadron,
L-NA (Light-Night Attack).
About the Author
It was in the Base Theater in Greensboro, NC, one night in August 1950. The
movie suddenly stopped and a Colonel stepped on stage. "We interrupt this movie
to tell you-THE WAR IS OVER!!" Joy erupted. The second announcement was that we
were all restricted to the base. I turned to the guy beside me and said, "This
calls for a drink." He agreed, and we left the theater for the "O" club. Thus
began a 60+ year friendship between the authors. Chet had just come back from
the 15th Air Force and Andy from the 8th. Through the years we got together in
such exotic places as London, El Paso, and Casablanca. When the Korean War
broke, Andy was among the initial Recallees. Chet was later recalled, and
joined us at George AFB.
Chet wrote his book, "Every Man a Tiger" in 1982. Several years later we
collaborated on a new book complete with pictures from our squadron history
book that we had compiled in Japan while waiting for orders to return to the
States. We agreed in 1995 that we needed to get a new book out with his as the
basis, and an expanded narrative that had been requested by the 731st members.
Andy added his chapters, along with other members. Thus was born "Involuntary."
Chet now resides in Little Rock, Arkansas, and Andy in Aztec, New Mexico.
Every Man a Tiger: The 731st United States Air Force Night Intruders over Korea
by Chester L. Blunk
Paperback: 128 pages Publisher: Sunfisher Books; ASIN: 0897450876; (May 1987)
Order Used
Out of Print--Limited Availability
B-26 Invader Units over Korea
by Warren E. Thompson
Price: $13.97
Edition: Paperback
Osprey Publications; ISBN: 1841760803; 1 edition (September 15, 2000)
Book Description
A seemingly haggard leftover from World War II, the B-26 proved one of the
greatest assets of UN forces in Korea. In fact, within hours of North Korea's
invasion of the south, B-26s were the first aircraft to drop ordnance on
communist forces. More than 200 bomber and recon variants saw action, many of
which were adorned with some of the most colorful nose art ever carried by
American combat aircraft. The author has used his extensive contact base to
accumulate one of the largest private collections of Korean color material in
the world. Accompanying the photos are detailed captions, quotes from pilots,
full appendices listing the units and B-26s that served in Korea, plus
specifications, cutaways of the aircraft, and cockpit diagrams.
Reviews
Reviewer: Kalani O'Sullivan: Used this book to document the 3rd BW. Though
only a few photos of the wing, it does an excellent job in gaining an
understanding of the B-26 missions. Some really fantastic bombing run shots
with pieces flying through the air captured -- meaning the aircraft was flying
WAY TOO LOW.
Douglas A-26 and B-26 Invader
by Scott M. Thompson
Price: $31.47
Edition: Hardcover
Crowood Pr; ISBN: 1861265034; (July 2002)
Book Description
This volume presents the complete story of the Douglas Invader medium bomber,
from its design and early history through WWII wartime service and peacetime
uses.
Reviews
Reviewer: Jack Kennedy from Snowmass Village, CO USA
Having flown and owned an On Mark executive conversion A-26B, I found Scott
Thompson's book to be very accurate and informative. A great historical and
insightful work about a truly significant aircraft.
Douglas A-26 Invader
by Frederick A. Johnsen
Price: $11.87
Edition: Paperback
Specialty Pr Pub & Wholesalers; ISBN: 1580070167; (July 1, 1999)
Book Description: Used in World War II, Korea, Vietnam, and modified for use as
an executive transport, this high-performing twin boasted state-of-the-art
design elements in its day, as well as a fatal flaw that emerged in Vietnam.
Johnsen provides a technical look at the strengths and weaknesses of this
aircraft through tech manual excerpts, cutaways, photos, and more.
F-80 Shooting Star Units over Korea
by Warren E. Thompson
Price: $13.97
Edition: Paperback
Osprey Pub Co; ISBN: 1841762253; (June 2001)
Reviews
Reviewer: Francis W.Meyer from Grove, Oklahoma United States
Warren Thompson is a friend of mine. I contributed information for his books.
In Chapter 5 there is mention of my encounter with a MIG15& I jettioned my Tip
Tanks to be more maneuverable & my wingman told me that the MIG on my tail flew
Into the tanks. This was never confirmed but so what I got back to K-14
(Kimpo)in one piece. Warren got with pilots like me who flew 100 combat
missions to be authentic & not full of stories. He is a Historian & an
excellent author. His Chapters regarding F-80Cs deals with the pilots flying
Fighter Bomber missions. These pilots along with F-84 pilots took the brunt of
combat losses. They did not have easy missions. I lost many friends. Francis W.
Meyer, Major USAF Retired
(Kalani O'Sullivan note: Used this book to document the 8th FBW of Suwon.
Excellent photographs with some very unusual shots.)
F-84 Thunderjet Units Over Korea
by Warren E. Thompson
Price: $13.97
Edition: Paperback
Stackpole Books; ISBN: 1841760226; (July 15, 2000)
Book Description: One of the key combat aircraft of the Korean War, the
straight-winged F-84 was a rugged design that could trace its lineage back to
Republic's pugnacious World War II P-47. Although built principally as a
fighter, the F-84 saw the bulk of its wartime service flying in a bomber role,
proving adept at striking at targets either in the frontline, or several
hundred miles into enemy territory. The first Thunderjets arrived in late 1950,
and quickly became the preferred fighter-bomber with Far East Air Forces. The
author has used his extensive contact base to accumulate one of the largest
private collections of Korean color material in the world. Accompanying the
photos are detailed captions, quotes from pilots, full appendices listing the
units and F-84s that served in Korea, plus specifications, cutaways of the
aircraft, and cockpit diagrams.
Reviews
Reviewer: Randy Presley from Mt. Pleasant, TX USA: Warren Thompson has done an
excellent job both pictorally and verbally describing one of the lesser known
but most effective weapons of the Korean War, The F-84 Thunderjet. I think the
F-84's in Korea may have flown more sorties than any other type. I flew 55
missions in the F-84G, took one AA hit in the wing and it brought me home
safely as it did many pilots. Since so many of our G models were given to NATO
countries, this model which was the best of the straight wing models, can
rarely be seen in a museum today in the U. S. I am buying two more books to
send to both the small USAF detachment at Taegu Air Base and the 110th Korean
Fighter Squadron for their history of the base which I recently visited after
48 years. ...
(Kalani O'Sullivan note: Randy Presley sent me a copy of this book and I must
admit that it is filled with a lot of details about the units. A lot of photos
of the 474th FBG that flew out of Kunsan AB with some nice shots of Wes
Jacobson's aircraft.)
Republic F-84: Thunderjet, Thunderstreak, & Thunderflash: A Photo Chronicle
(Schiffer Military/Aviation History)
by David R. McLaren
Paperback: 207 pages ; Publisher: Schiffer Publishing, Ltd.; ISBN: 0764304445;
(February 1998)
Price: $29.95
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
The Republic Aviation Corporation F-84 series, the Thunderjet, Thunderstreak,
and Thunderflash was the United States Air Forces' first Post World War II jet
fighter. As a somewhat sad result of this, it has been ignored by most aviation
historians and aficionados. It was not the Air Forces' first operational jet
fighter, as that honor went to the Lockheed F-80 which was created during World
War II. And it did not receive the glory of the North American Aviation F-86,
which followed it in sequence and was more photogenic, faster, and more
involved in the glory of aerial combat. Nevertheless, the F-84 performed its
unheralded role in a true yeoman fashion. It, and its pilots and groundcrews,
fought the air-to-mud role as a fighter bomber in Korea. It served as an
interceptor, and in photo reconnaissance. It was the first jet fighter to be
operationally capable of air refueling, and it was the first to be able to
deliver a nuclear weapon. 4300 of the straight-wing F-84s were built, along
with 2713 of the swept-wing F-84Fs, and 715 of the reconnaissance RF-84Fs.
Almost 8000 unrecognized fighters, of which half of those produced served as a
deterrent to enemy forces during the Cold War while being flown by friendly
foreign countries., over 450 b/w and color photographs, 8 1/2" x 11"
Reviewer: A reader from St. Charles, IL The best one so far!, or is it the only
one?, March 5, 1999
I really enjoyed and have bought three of them for my old airforce buddies. The
F-84 is such a forgotten airplane, it is amazing that anyone found so many
pictures. Enjoy!
F-86 Sabre Fighter-Bomber Units over Korea
by Warren E. Thompson
Price: $13.97
Edition: Paperback
Osprey Pub Co; ISBN: 1855329298; (March 2000)
Book Description
130 color photographs, 7 x 9
This volume illustrates all the users of the F-86F, including the South African
Air Forces No.2 Squadron which flew with the 18th FBW, in contemporary wartime
color. Never before published photos of Korean War F-86s from private
collections are complemented by detailed captions, quotes from pilots in action
and an appendices of the units that served in Korea, plus
specifications/cutaways of the aircraft flown.
Reviews
Reviewer: Jim Schmidt from Fresno, CA USA
Osprey's author Warren Thompson has woven an excellent collection of candid and
"formal" photos with historical information and personal stories to give the
reader a real "I was there" experience.
The focus of the book is operational, and with the exception of a cutaway
drawing and pertinent specs of an F-84-30, there is little technical data. But
if you want to know what it was like to be assigned to a Sabre squadron in
Korea, look no further.
There are dozens of photos in sharp, clear, brilliant color, with detailed
captions that flesh out the "story line" with additional information, adding to
the reader's immersion in the era.
The only criticism I have is that the type face is kinda small and would be
easier to read if it was bolder. Big deal! :)
The bottom line is that this is a "must have" for any F-86 nut, and I am
looking forward to picking up the other volumes in Osprey's "over Korea" series
(F-51, F-84 and B-26)
F-51 Mustang Units over Korea
by Warren E. Thompson
Price: $13.97
Edition: Paperback
Osprey Pub Co; ISBN: 1855329174; (September 1999)
Book Description
130 color photographs, 7 x 9
This volume illustrates all the users of the F-51/RF-51 during the Korean War
in contemporary color. Some of the most colorful Mustangs ever to see action,
and the author has accumulated the largest private collection of Korean color
material in the world. Accompanying the photos are detailed captions, quotes
from pilots in action and a full appendices listing of the various units that
served in Korea, plus specifications and cutaways of the aircraft flown.
Reviews
Reviewer: Mark A. Olinger: Warren Thompson has given the air enthusiasts,
historians, and Mustang buffs an excellent start in Osprey's "Frontline Color"
series. F-51 Mustang Units over Korea contains a great deal of information and
carefully selected color photos of all US and UN users of F-51/RF-51s during
the Korean War. This book covers a much overlooked area of aviation history
dealing with F-51 operations and units in Korea. The facts about Australian,
South Korean, and South African units were an extra bonus. This book gives
these outstanding pilots, ground crews, and units their due.
Perfect for US Air Force, Royal Australian Air Force, South African Air Force
and South Korean Mustang enthusiasts. It is a great book and I recommend it
highly. If you want an operational overview of the F-51 Mustangs you wouldn't
go wrong with this book - well worth the price and time to read.
Kalani O'Sullivan note: Exceptional shots of the 8th FBG (Hobo Squadron) in
North Korea.
Corsair: The F4U in World War II and Korea
by Barrett Tillman, Kenneth A. Walsh (Foreword)
Paperback: 219 pages ; Publisher: Naval Institute Press; ISBN: 1557509948; 3rd
edition (March 12, 2002)
Price: $13.27
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
This is the remarkable story of an airplane that became a legend--with a sleek
silhouette and bent wings, it doubled as a day and night fighter, could fly off
carriers or from land, and served both as a dive bomber and reconnaissance
plane. Filled with facts and figures, this fast-paced history begins with the
nerve-wracking test flights of the 1940s and concludes with the F4Us that were
active thirty-eight years later. Placed skillfully in between are the stories
that gave birth to the legend: the exploits of the aces, including the Medal of
Honor recipient who shot down twenty-five enemy planes, and the details of the
combat missions of Charles A. Lindbergh. During thirty months of combat in
World War II with the U.S. Navy and Marines, the Corsair shot down more than
two thousand Japanese planes. In Korea the U-bird, as it was called, was
credited with ten aerial victories.
A trip down memory lane for anyone who has followed the career of this Cadillac
of the props, this new paperback edition of a book first published in hardcover
in 1979 offers fine historical aviation reading that presents a riveting
picture of the men and machine that helped win two wars.
Reviewer: Dirk Broer from Leiden, the Netherlands Nice background read for
Corsair enthousiasts, June 30, 2002
Though not the book I would recommend to my girlfriend, I read it in one
session from front to cover. Is it because I was born too late to fly this
plane myself? The nice thing for me about this book is that I got the feeling
that it took me back in time and let me experience wat it was like -or at least
what I thought it would be like-. There are enough photographs to prevent you
from drowning in text and evere aspect of the plane gets covered, with the
exception of what it was to maintain a Corsair airworthy for its groundcrews.
This book was published in the States by the United States Naval Institute and
in Britain by PSL (Patrick Stepens Limited)
Reviewer: Duncan C. McDougall from Campton, NH United States War Baby's View,
December 30, 2001
Born in 1943, I spent my youth building balsa Corsairs (and Mustangs, Hellcats,
Warhawks, Spitfires and Hurricanes) covered with silkspan, and reading of their
exploits in WWII and Korea. There must be millions of us Fifty- and
Sixty-somethings in America still feeling we were born too late to have a
chance to fly the great fighters of WWII. For us, Tillman is a timely author.
We buy and read his well-told histories with feelings of respect for the
designers, builders, test pilots, pilots and crews who made that great age of
the piston-powered warbirds possible.
Avoiding the dreary repetitiveness of some such books, which seem bound to
chronicle every squadron's every mission, Tillman's Corsair is an exceptionally
good example of its breed. It combines valuable historical detail with
first-hand accounts of the plane and its pilots in action. --This text refers
to the Hardcover edition.
Reviewer: Lance D. Johnson from Champaign, Illinois BarrettTillman's"Corsair",
February 15, 2000
This offering by Barrett Tilllman is one of the more readable accounts of WWII
naval aviation. Tillman goes into enough depth to give the reader an
appreciation for the technology and engineering involved in the F4U Corsair,
but rightly devotes most of the book to the stories of the aviators who flew
the "Ensign Eliminator" in combat. Anecdotes related to the author by veteran
Corsair drivers, added to Tillman's own knowledge and experience in flying WWII
aircraft lend authenticity to the work. Very well researched, this book is a
valuable resource for the student of WWII or aviation,but its style also
recomends it to the casual reader. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
Bent Wings - F4U Corsair Action and Accidents
by Fred Blechman
Paperback: 376 pages ; Publisher: Xlibris Corporation; ISBN: 0738803464; 1
edition (May 1999)
Price: $18.00
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
You are in an F4U Corsair, turning toward the carrier and preparing all the
controls for a night carrier landing. You are dive-bombing the Japanese
battleship Yamato. You are in combat and watch your best friend get shot down
About the Author
Fred Blechman flew F4U-5 Corsairs with the VF-14 Tophatters. He made two
Mediterranean carrier cruises, and numerous Caribbean carrier deployments from
1950-1952. Since 1961 he has written 750 magazine articles and seven books
about microcomputers, electronics and flying.
Reviewer: Michael Masotto from Southern California Get into the Cockpit with
Fred, January 9, 2001 Told as several short stories, Bent Wings is a collection
of what would otherwise be a "Pilots' Hangar Talk," stories from one pilot to
another. From the start, the author straps you in and puts you in control of
his F4U Corsair. Soon, your at 30,000 feet flying among the rainbows.
Many of the stories are devoted to activities of young F4U Corsair pilots, with
actual accident reports and photos of both good and bad landing. An F4U Corsair
pilot himself, the author reflects his experience as an aviator in a smooth
easy to read style that both pilots and land-lovers will enjoy.
If you've ever dreamed of what it would have been like to fly an F4U Corsair,
read "Bent Wings."
Reviewer: Scott Lucas from Washington, DC Bent Wings - F4UCorsair Action and
Accidents, February 28, 2000 I met my first Corsair in Ordnance School at the
Naval Air Station in Jacksonville, Florida, on my way to Pensacola and a career
in Naval Aviation. In the early summer evenings, I would go down to the hanger
and sit in the cockpit, dreaming of things to come. Circumstances got in the
way, the career didn't work out, and I never got to fly a Corsair. But I did
fly the T-28 Trojan -- better visibility, yet the same kind of attitude,
throaty roaring sound, and serious torque problems. Even without this
familiarity, Fred makes it possible to fly with him and the other contributors
in a series of vignettes every bit as exciting as an action/adventure literary
effort. You can see the animated activity of the flight deck, you can feel the
newness of it to these fledgling pilots, you can feel the excitement and yes,
the terror, the fear of error. And you can almost smell the hot engine oil and
hear the thunder of thousands of horsepower unleashed in that huge radial
engine. Be in the air at night, with the golden sun dropping into the ocean,
the majesty and beauty bringing tears to your eyes, and then the sudden horror
at the realization; you have to put this pig down on a matchbook! One can see
why it is widely thought that Navy pilots are the finest trained in the world.
It's also easy to understand Fred's dubious achievement of being America's
honorary Japanese Ace in Corsairs, having downed five of the aircraft one way
or another. Come fly with Fred, come fly, lets fly away! --This text refers to
the Hardcover edition.
Reviewer: A reader from Mojave Desert Fun Read, January 18, 2000
I met Mr. Blechman at Chino Planes of Fame Corsair Demonstration Day and he
enthusiastically signed his book for me! I could hardly wait to get home and
read it and I was not let down. I have long been fascinated by the hog and the
stories in his book helped me experience the art of flying the long nose bird
vicariously. I finally have a good appreciation for just how difficult a
machine it was to land aboard an air craft carrier. Well done Mr. Blechman.
Whistling Death: The Test Pilot's Story of the F4U Corsair
by Boone T. Guyton
Hardcover: 272 pages Publisher: Schiffer Publishing, Ltd.; ISBN: 0887407323;
(January 1995)
Price: $25.00
Editorial Reviews
From Book News, Inc.
The story, by the test pilot, of the crash program (and attendant crash
landings) to produce the Corsair, the Navy fighter that brought America air
superiority over the Japanese Zero in WWII. With 16 pages of glossy b&w
photographs. Annotation copyright Book News, Inc. Portland, Or. --This text
refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Book Description
Whistling Death is the true story, by the test pilot, of the rush to produce
the F4U Corsair, the Navy fighter that brought America air superiority over the
Japanese Zero in World War II. Here is the crash program - complete with crash
landings - powered by the dedicated men and women of the home front who
designed and built this revolutionary, tide-turning airplane. Boone T. Guyton,
an experimental test pilot at Chance Vought during and after World War II, flew
105 types of aircraft in 45 years as a pilot. , 16 pages of photographs, 6" x
9"
F4U Corsair in Action (Aircraft No. 145)
by Jim Sullivan, Don Greer (Illustrator), Joe Sewell (Drawings)
Paperback: 58 pages Publisher: Squadron/Signal Pubns; ISBN: 0897473183;
(January 2001)
Price: $9.95
F4U Corsair (Motorbooks International Warbird History)
by Nicholas A. Veronico, John M. Campbell (Contributor), Donna Campbell, Nick
Veronico
Paperback: 144 pages ; Publisher: Motorbooks International; ASIN: 0879388544; ()
Used from $61.34
Reviewer: A reader from California,USA A good photo-summary..heavier on Korea
than WWII, September 10, 1999
Not a bad collection of color F4U Korea photos, and general Corsair summary.
Worth the $ to add to your library.
Reviewer: A reader from Portland, Oregon One of the best F4U books!, February
11, 1999
Well worth the price, and probably the best F4U book written to date. This book
examines each model with stories from aces, test pilots, and others who flew
the plane. Good coverage of the radar equipped night fighters, Corsairs in
service in South America, in the movies, and RACERS! Too bad it wasn't put out
in hardback.
Vought F4U Corsair (Warbird Tech Series , Vol 4)
by Barrett Tillman
Paperback: 100 pages ; Publisher: Voyageur Press; ASIN: 0933424671; (September
1996)
Used from $18.95
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
The WarbirdTech series is the first new, innovative look at military aircraft
to arrive in the marketplace in the last fifteen years. Individual volumes in
this series provide a first-ever "layman's technical" analysis and review of
the world's most exciting combat aircraft. Included are photos, drawings and
excerpts from previously "secret" and "restricted" technical manuals produced
by the government and the aircraft manufacturers. Included are vintage photos
of aircraft during prototype and manufacturing stages, exploded views, cutaways
and phantom drawings form tech manuals, disassembled aircraft, rare variants
and experimental models etc. Special emphasis is placed on the unique and
ground-breaking design and performance aspects of each aircraft.
This series is for the enthusiast who has read all the combat stories, seen all
the camouflage and markings books and now wants to learn the fascinating
technical details behind the design and performance of combat aircraft.
An 01-45Hd-1 Pilot's Handbook Navy Models F4U-5, -5N, -5Nl, -5P Aircraft
Paperback: 102 pages Publisher: Schiffer Publishing, Ltd.; ISBN: 0887408214;
(August 1995)
Price: $19.95
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
A facsimile reprint of the pilot's handbook for the F4U-5, -5N, -5NL, and -5P.,
photographs and drawings, 8 1/2" x 11"
Reviewer: Claudio Bompadre from Rome Italy A rarity in technical publications,
June 6, 2001
This facsimile reprint is the actual flight manual for F4U-5 Corsair, US Navy
fighter aircraft. It is the Pilot's Handbook as published in 1951, when the
plane was at the end of his career, following its tremendous success in II
World War (it is basically the same type flown by Marine Major Pappy Boyngton,
leader of the famous Squadron VFM 214 "Black Sheeps"). The handbook is a
wonderful source of informations because the layout is forerunner of modern
military aircraft manuals; as for its contents we can find all the details of
cockpit arrangements, normal and emergency checklists, several descriptions on
operational equipments such as the radar system used for the Night Fighter
version. Finally, for the technicalities maniac, real operating instructions
charts (referring to external load configuration), power plant and flying
perfomance charts are available in appendix.
This is a useful tool for the warbird enthusiast to understand the aircraft
achievements as narrated by many volumes such as " The Skull & Crossbones
Squadron VF 17 in IIWW" or "Whistling Death-The test pilot story of the F4U
Corsair", and to explain the longevity and versatility of this well-known
airplane.
F7F Tigercat in Action (Aircraft, No 79)
by W.E. Scarborough
Paperback: Publisher: Squadron/Signal Pubns; ASIN: 0897471881; (July 1987)
Order Used
Reviewer: barker-smith@worldnet.att.net from Kenneth Smith, Belleview, Florida
USA Excellent history of an outstanding plane., November 3, 1997
The author put togther a great history of a military aircraft that had a short
history because of the timing of its birth. It was the best of the best, but
was soon replaced by jets. The history is remarkable accurate. I know because I
was there, and flew several hundred hours in the bird. The author captured the
spririt of great plane, and gathered photos and names that portrayed it as it
was. Good presentation of a rare subject.
Douglas F3d Skyknight (Naval Fighters Series No 4)
by Steven J. Ginter
Paperback: Publisher: Naval Fighters; ISBN: 0942612043; (March 1982)
Price: $14.98
In Mortal Combat : Korea, 1950-1953
by John Toland
Paperback Rep edition (June 1993)
Price: $11.20
From Kirkus Reviews , August 15, 1991
For an ostensibly forgotten war, the Korean ``police action'' has commanded a
lot of literary attention in recent years. Unfortunately, Toland (Infamy, Adolf
Hitler, The Last Hundred Days, etc.) does not add a great deal to available
lore. In fact, though he draws on some fresh sources, there are no new or
startling perspectives in this readable, if sometimes perverse and portentous,
narrative overview of the conflict. A diligent researcher, Toland makes a
generally good job of putting the war's first year into human-scale focus,
documenting the murderous battles that raged from the mid-1950 Communist
invasion of the South through the Pusan, Inchon, Chosin, and allied campaigns.
He's equally competent, if often elusively contrarian, at capturing the big
picture, offering short-take interpretations of the war's causes and course. He
shows, for example, how the US failed to heed China's clear warnings that it
required North Korea as a buffer state. Despite a conspicuous (and admitted)
lack of evidence, however, Toland leaves open the question of whether the
Allies employed biological weapons. Along similar lines, he taxes Truman with
prolonging the stalemated fighting by virtue of his insistence on voluntary
repatriation of all POWs. Like most annalists, Toland concludes that the Korean
War ended when peace talks began at Kaesong. As he nonetheless makes clear in
his summary coverage, it took two more years to negotiate a cease-fire, during
which time American and Chinese troops engaged one another, sustaining tens of
thousands of casualties in the bloody, purposeless process. A
less-than-balanced accounting of what was won and lost in a clash of arms that
aroused precious little interest, much less passion, on the home front. Among
other superior alternatives, Bevin Alexander's Korea (1986) and Max Hastings's
The Korean War (1987) stand out. The sparsely annotated text has 55 photographs
and 18 helpful maps. -- Copyright ©1991, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights
reserved. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this
title.
Synopsis
In this brilliant narrative of America's first limited war, Toland shows again
why, for over 20 years, he has been one of the most respected and popular
military historians. He lets both the events and participants speak for
themselves, employing scrupulous archival research and interviews as the basis
for the drama and accuracy of his writing. Photos and maps.
Reviews
K. W. CLARK DAV 5th RCT (KEJACLARK@AOL.COM) from SEATTLE , October 6, 1999
inaccurate data
THE BOOK IS OK, BUT TOLAND STATES THAT THE 555 FIELD ART. WAS AND ALL BLACK
OUTFIT. NOT TRUE. THE TRIPPLE NICKLE WAS AND ALL WHITE OUTFIT IN 1950-51, AND
WAS ATTACHED TO THE 5th R.C.T. DURING THAT TIME.
arnoldhoward@yahoo.com from Mesquite, Texas , January 23, 1999
A Riveting Account of the Korean War
If you have any illusions about the glory of war, read this book. John Toland,
through detailed interviews, shows the reader the horrors of battle. It is
riveting and a must-read for anyone interested in the Orient.
dgb1@ixpres.com from San Diego, CA , December 8, 1998
Good Book and somewhat like the real War ... due to the fact that it has a
strong and interesting beginning, a somewhat "vanilla" middle , and a rather
"limp" ending. I am not a military historian, but am an analyst. I am not a
veteran, but do understand the difference between the various types of
"histories",i.e. academic military history, journalistic military history,
popular military history ("coffee table" books, etc.), "official histories",
oral history, etc.
This book definately falls into the journalistic history category, with all it
pitfalls and advantages. One pitfall is that Mr. Toland is FAR too easy on the
press in general and he doesn't spend much time at all on faults of the
forementioned press. On the other hand, one of the advantages is that this book
is a wonderful "read", i.e. the book has a definite flow to it (along with
being easy to read).
In my opinion, the book, like some of his other books, starts off very strong
and detailed and then proceeds to a somewhat bland middle and finishes with a
rather "limp" ending. [The book of his that epitimizes this is: The Rising
Sun!] His discussion of Generals Walker and MacArthur are very good indeed and
better than most other books (considering that he does it better in FAR less
space/wording). Another strong suit of this book is the insight and discussion
of POWS and their treatment. He also, does give a view of the "other side of
the hill", which other so-called "histories of the Korean War" fail to do.
However, in the middle of the book I would have liked to see more detailed
discussion on some of the "nitty-gritty" tactical battles once the Chinese
entered the war (as by this pt. in the book he just covers entire campaigns at
the division and Corps level, with just "snippets" of tactical action).
Finally, the last group of chapters in the book, "WAR & PEACE", could have been
much better. He only covers the political bickering between the two sides and
almost completely ignores ANY of the many interesting tactical struggles going
on all along the "static" front line (MLR). IF he would have covered more than
just the one he did, it would have GREATLY enhanced the book for me.
A reader from United States , November 10, 1998
A detailed and chilling account of a war so often overlooked
Toland depicts the Korean War with such detail and accuracy that it becomes
impossible to romantisize war. The soldiers were against overwhelming odds in
extreme conditions, and constantly in a struggle to stay alive. By retelling
the war from the perspective of all the key generals in the war, or from a
close observer of a general, Toland gave us their insight to why they made the
decisions that they did. He also captured many of these key decisions in the
epilogue detailing the weaknesses and mistakes of the key leaders. His
historical accuracy of the carnage produced on both sides made it a chilling
reminder of the horrors of war. The lengthy cat and mouse game played between
the governments of the United States, North Korea, and China to sign the peace
agreement lasted over a year while American soldiers suffered in POW camps. I
wasn't born at the time, but reading it now made me angry as the battles
continued to produce casualties as did the POW camps. Very good book!
Irawalker@bellsouth.net from Nashville, TN , July 7, 1998
I've read better accounts.
Toland interviewed me along with others, for this book. I was there from Aug to
Dec. 1950. His accounts of battles is at times pretty accurate, but I think he
wandered off in some of his political punditry. I don't believe Mr. Toland did
his best work here. Fehrenbach's This Kind of War, is far superior, both in
style and content. I never heard anything but sarcasm from the grunt level when
Higgins was mentioned. Some of her interviews with the troops were ludicrous.
Toland spends more time and effort on her than it's worth.
Rethinking the Korean War: A New Diplomatic and Strategic History
by William Whitney Stueck
Hardcover: 304 pages ; Princeton Univ Pr; ISBN: 0691088535; (September 2002)
Price: $29.95
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
Fought on what to Westerners was a remote peninsula in northeast Asia, the
Korean War was a defining moment of the Cold War. It militarized a conflict
that previously had been largely political and economic. And it solidified a
series of divisions--of Korea into North and South, of Germany and Europe into
East and West, and of China into the mainland and Taiwan--which were to persist
for at least two generations. Two of these divisions continue to the present,
marking two of the most dangerous political hotspots in the post-Cold War
world. The Korean War grew out of the Cold War, it exacerbated the Cold War,
and its impact transcended the Cold War.
William Stueck presents a fresh analysis of the Korean War's major diplomatic
and strategic issues. Drawing on a cache of newly available information from
archives in the United States, China, and the former Soviet Union, he provides
an interpretive synthesis for scholars and general readers alike. Beginning
with the decision to divide Korea in 1945, he analyzes first the origins and
then the course of the conflict. He takes into account the balance between the
international and internal factors that led to the war and examines the
difficulty in containing and eventually ending the fighting. This discussion
covers the progression toward Chinese intervention as well as factors that both
prolonged the war and prevented it from expanding beyond Korea. Stueck goes on
to address the impact of the war on Korean-American relations and evaluates the
performance and durability of an American political culture confronting a
challenge from authoritarianism abroad.
Stueck's crisp yet in-depth analysis combines insightful treatment of past
events with a suggestive appraisal of their significance for present and
future.
From the Inside Flap
"This is a fresh, comprehensive, and balanced study that anyone interested in
the Korean War--and, more broadly, in the development of the global Cold
War--will find the need to read. Supported by insights gained from new sources
and demonstrating a high sensitivity toward the international nature of the
conflict in Korea, it is of great scholarly significance." (Chen Jian,
University of Virginia)
This Kind of War: The Classic Korean War History
by T. R. Fehrenbach
Paperback: 540 pages ; Brasseys, Inc.; ISBN: 1574883348; 50th Annv edition
(March 21, 2001)
Price: $24.95
Editorial Reviews
Washington Post
"A comprehensve and impressively written history of the Korean War."
From Book News, Inc.
Originally published by MacMillan in 1963 as This Kind of War: A Study in
Unpreparedness. Fehrenbach (a former commander of US Army units in Korea)
presents a broad view of events in the Korean and international arenas along
with the personal narratives of individual soldiers. Includes a chronology and
a descriptive glossary of the principle weapons used. Annotation copyright Book
News, Inc. Portland, Or. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
Reviewer: Michael Dickson from Pátzcuaro, Michoacán, Mexico Story of the
Forgotten War, told by a Real He-Man, June 15, 2001
This book was republished in the late-1990s, and I suspect it was tidied up a
bit to reflect modern society. The book I read was the original 1963 edition
that I unearthed in an ancient library in the middle of Mexico. By "tidied up a
bit," I mean that I imagine the references to the Chinese "hordes" of "little,
coffee-colored" men have been deleted or altered to reflect the dainty
political correctness loose across the land.
But, maybe not.
I was almost 6 years old when the Korean "Conflict" broke out. I wasn't paying
much attention. Like most Americans, I grew up knowing little of the event
because it has mostly been erased from the American consciousness. There are
little, or no, reunions of Korean vets or POWs. It, like Vietnam, was a
miserable mess, and the United States didn't win. However, unlike Vietnam,
which the North Vietnamese won, nobody won in Korea. It was just a bloody
disaster, bloodier than most people know. Over 2 million people died, 40,000 of
them U.S. servicemen.
Our author, a thoroughly military T.R. Fehrenbach, does a complete job of
writing history. Sometimes the details, however, are a bit much. Take this
paragraph, for instance:
"When R/B (roadblock) is open, follow this priority for movement south: (1)
38th Inf (2) 2nd Recon Co, Div HQ, MP Co, 2nd Signal Co (3) Divarty (divisional
Artillery) (4) 2nd Engr Bn (5) Rearguard - 23rd RCT (23red Inf, 15 FA Bn, 72d
Tank Bn - Co C, Batery B of 82d AAA."
OK, thankfully, that type of paragraph is rare, at least in length. But there
is a lot of military jargon in this book. Great for soldiers and staunch
military buffs, I guess, but it's a little much for your average reader.
Of note also is Fehrenbach's hairy-handed chest-thumping. He's a real man's
man, and if you didn't know it, he tells you, over and over. But, it's military
history, so what do you want? Jane Fonda? Pee-Wee Herman?
The war went something like this: The North Korean hordes came crashing down
into South Korea in June 1950. They and their tanks pushed the totally
surprised and unprepared Americans and South Koreans into a southeastern niche
of South Korea called the Pusan Perimeter. Fehrenbach attributes this in large
part to the lackluster U.S. armed forces at the time, full of guys who didn't
know what they were doing or why they were there. Military training after World
War II became soft and sissy. Just ask Fehrenbach. He'll tell you.
After some heavy-duty attitude changing and reinforcing, the U.S., augmented by
other United Nations troops, pushed the North Koreans back into North Korea and
then on up to the Yalu River, the border of Manchuria. At that point, the
Chinese, those little, coffee-colored Commies, got involved. They pushed the
U.S./U.N. forces back down to near the 38th Parallel, about to where the
original border between North and South Korea had been before the war.
At this point, about midway through the three-year war, everybody dug in. It
became a war quite similar to the trench warfare of World War I. Peace talks
began. And they dragged on...and on...and on...while people continued to die in
droves along the front. There were artillery barrages and countless see-saw
attacks on hills with names like Bloody Ridge, Pork Chop and Heartbreak. All
for naught.
This is a good, solid history. It apparently is considered the definitive book
on the Korean War. It was a sad, tragic war that ended without a formal peace.
It ended just about where it began, except for all those corpses, parching in
the sunshine. Fehrenbach hits all the bases: The Inch'on landings. Truman's
sacking of the headstrong Gen. MacArthur. The conflicts of world opinion. The
troubles with POWs, both North and South. The tough Turk troops with the long
bayonets. Eisenhower's election in 1952. The list goes on.
I have a few more complaints. There are lots of photos, but the photo captions
don't tell you who is who, which is ridiculous. There will be a photo of a
bunch of guys talking. The caption will say something like: Gen. Walker confers
with Col. Smith. It leaves you wondering. Which one is Walker? Which is Smith?
And Fehrenbach really can preach. A little less preaching would have been nice.
He's always telling us how things should have been done, according to the
Gospel of Fehrenbach. Maybe the book would have been shorter than the 700-plus
pages in my edition if he had just put a lid on it.
But, I quibble. Good history, and I recommend it to you. As much as you will
ever need to know about this terrible Forgotten War. --This text refers to the
Paperback edition.
Reviewer: Larry R. Duncan (alizu@telcel.net.ve) from Maracaibo, Venezuela Memo
to NYTimes: Read something besides your own scratchings, October 25, 1999 I
read this book more than 30 years ago but the poignant, tradgic story, dealt
with so unflinchingly here, about the blowing of the bridge over the Naktong
River crowded with refugees has stayed with me. That this story, in the public
domain for more than 30 years, would be played as a front page scoop by the
NYTimes is ludicrous. Don't the editors of the US "newspaper of record" read
anymore? This book is the definitive history of that war and is only one of
only a handful of references available. Mr. Fehrenbach is still alive and
writing, with the same elan and clarity seen in TKOW, a regular column in the
San Antonio Express and no doubt available to the editors of the Times should
they want to fact check their scoops. It's a real page turner, you will not be
able to put it down. --This text refers to the Paperback edition.
Reviewer: A reader from Big D. From one who was there, its factual., April 29,
2002
Unprepared, Yes. But it was the people who ordered the Army divisions to the
Yalu, knowing from the G-2 in Japan that the Chinese were inside Korea in
October. Willoughby, the G-2 was specifically asked and the answer he gave, was
at best evasive.
"They are just volunteers". If you've viewed the picture of two Army personnel,
with a light 30 cal. machine gun, with an overview of Manchuria and the Yalu,
then you will understand. It was grandstanding by Tokyo to release same but you
wont see pictures of the 2nd and 7th Divisions going south to keep from being
annihiliated, all for the ego of MacArthur. Feherenbach, tells you what he went
thru, and the most remaining MIA's of that era are still in the northern part
of Korea. Ask CILHI??? --This text refers to the Mass Market Paperback edition.
Reviewer: secession from Beverly Hills, CA USA Informative, but leaves A LOT
to be desired...., March 29, 2002 As an American-born Korean, I obviously have
some personal interest in the subject matter, and while I already was possessed
of some basic knowledge about the events of 1950-53, I felt I needed a more
thorough grounding in the actual battles and the characters of the Korean War.
While Mr. Fehrenbach's volume did much to keep me informed about the major
clashes, the involved units, and the prominent people, I often found myself
bogged down in his often very confusingly organized prose. Never mind writing
style -- I often found myself baffled as to just what he was trying to say, or
about whom he was trying to say it. Not to mention abominable copywriting,
which wouldn't normally bother me so much, except that the frequent punctuation
errors and misspellings often just hampered the text's comprehensibility even
more.
And as one reviewer here previously stated, Mr. Fehrenbach does indeed have a
personal axe to grind, which in and of itself wouldn't be so remarkable (few
historians can avoid inserting a healthy dose of their own personal biases into
their works), except that it oftentimes leads him to keep reaching for the same
tired metaphors that might've been meaningful used once, but just seem like
laziness the second or third time around. (Yes, we know "there are tigers," Mr.
Fehrenbach, but you don't have to keep saying so every other page....) Another
big problem I had with this history was the total lack of maps illustrating
what he was trying to describe in his often clumsy prose. Even as a Korean, I
often had trouble following the litany of names of towns, rivers, and
mountains, without a single point of reference to get a better idea of what he
was referring to.
He obviously had a great passion for the topic, and many of his points about
the changing nature of warfare were (and are) cogent, but its many shortcomings
made for an oftentimes all-too-frustrating read.
The Korean War
by Max Hastings
Paperback: ; Publisher: Touchstone Books; ISBN: 067166834X; Reprint edition
(October 1988)
Price: $10.50
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
It was the first war we could not win. At no other time since World War II have
two superpowers met in battle. Now Max Hastings, preeminent military historian
takes us back to the bloody bitter struggle to restore South Korean
independence after the Communist invasion of June 1950. Using personal accounts
from interviews with more than 200 vets -- including the Chinese -- Hastings
follows real officers and soldiers through the battles. He brilliantly captures
the Cold War crisis at home -- the strategies and politics of Truman, Acheson,
Marshall, MacArthur, Ridgway, and Bradley -- and shows what we should have
learned in the war that was the prelude to Vietnam.
Ingram
A vivid and meticulous assessment of one of the most misunderstood episodes in
recent history, this is a look back to the first war we could not win--not just
the big picture, but also a look inside the experience of soldiers in the
battle. 76 black-and-white photos.
Reviewer: A reader from Planet Ohio See yourself as others see you., June 10,
1999
I thought it was a pretty good book. Hastings describes some of the American
shortcomings as illuminated by declassified British military memos describing
poor discipline during the early part of the war. He also describes the air
war, including what was like to be stationed out in the Pacific servicing and
arming B-29's.
As a draftee I spent some time in South Korea in 1971 and 1972. It's good to
have some more background on what went on there during the war.
Reviewer: Capt Keith Kopets, USMC from Eugene, Oregon Korean War Readers:
Advance Cautiously, February 13, 2000
The interpretations of the Korean War are varied and number almost as many as
the pages that have been devoted to the conflict's history. The Korean War is
an attempt by the British author Max Hastings to paint a portrait of the war,
focusing upon some human and military aspects less familiar to readers on both
sides of the Atlantic. From the outset, Hastings does not purport to give a
comprehensive account of the war and cites the works of David Rees (Korea: The
Limited War, New York, 1964) and Bruce Cumings (Origins of the Korean War, New
Jersey, 1981) as the best in these categories. The author also professes his
belief in the rightness of the American commitment to Korea in 1950. One of the
more interesting passages in the Korean War is the author's coverage of the
Inchon operation. Hastings defends the decision of General MacArthur to
maintain X Corps as a separate tactical unit from Eighth Army: ...
there was an entirely legitimate case for placing the conduct of the Inchon
landing in hands other than those of General Walton Walker. MacArthur well knew
the low morale that existed in Eighth Army headquarters....
[Although] Walker had conducted a stubborn defense of Pusan....
there was grave reason to doubt his ability now to lead the sort of imaginative
and dynamic operation MacArthur planned. MacArthur considered, and rejected,
the possibility of relieving him [Walker] of his command....
MacArthur's compromise was to entrust the amphibious operation to Almond. The
author's argument is plausible, but he fails to cite his references. One of the
strong points of the Korean War is the author's analysis ofthe Chinese and
their intervention in the war. Hastings visited Peking while researching this
book and incorporates the oral histories gained from interviewing veterans of
the People's Liberation Army. He succeeds in using this material (although his
journalistic, vice scholarly use of oral history gives the book a spurious
creditability) in supporting his main thrust regarding the Chinese; that
patriotism, not Communism, drove their intervention. The Chinese viewed the
naval blockade of Formosa as a threat to their sovereignty; the Chinese sought
the liberation of Taiwan and now equated the attainment of this goal with the
defeat of the United States. Additionally, the Chinese refused to remain idle
with the approach of foreign troops towards their border: Throughout the Korean
War, Washington persistently sought the communist ideological logic behind
Chinese actions. It might have been more profitable to consider instead
historic Chinese nationalistic logic. Korea had provided the springboard for
the Japanese invasion of Manchuria only a generation before. As the Americans
drove north after smashing Kim Il Sung's armies in September 1950, Peking was
appalled by the imminent prospect of an American imperialist army on the Yalu.
(p. 134) Hastings also refutes the belief by the United States that the Chinese
were acting in concert with the Soviet Union. The Russians regretted the North
Korean's invasion and wished to distance themselves from Korea; thus, the
Chinese acted unilaterally Hastings, to his credit, also gives ample analysis
of the misjudgments of the Communists. The Chinese, after their initial success
in late 1950, were led into the same trap as the United States after Inchon:
they allowed their military success to change their original political goals.
However limited the war aims of the Chinese in November 1950, there is no doubt
that their early triumphs opened up, in the eyes of Peking, illusory visions of
absolute military victory in Korea, of an all-embracing Communist success.
Hastings argues correctly that the Chinese would have greatly boosted their own
prestige had they sought a negotiated end to the struggle after the winter of
1950. Nevertheless, his argument that China lost a prime opportunity to gain a
seat in the United Nations by not negotiating a truce after 1950 is a weak one.
Al |